The Environmental Action Committee of West Marin (EAC) recognizes that there are concerns in the Bolinas community regarding our petition to increase protections at the existing Duxbury Reef State Marine Conservation Area (SMCA) by designating it as a State Marine Reserve (SMR) and expanding its boundaries north and south to cover the entirety of the reef habitat. We are also aware that there are misconceptions about what the petition would do, and we seek to clarify them.
Advocating for 30x30 and a Strong Definition of “Conserved”
On June 10th, we spoke at the Ocean Protection Council (OPC) meeting to discuss California’s 30x30 initiative and how its framework will apply to coastal waters, as well as advocating for funding for marine protected area enforcement. In 2020, Governor Gavin Newsom issued an executive order known as the “30x30” initiative, which set the goal of conserving 30% of California’s lands and coastal waters by 2030. 30x30 was designed to foster collaboration among various organizations to conserve and restore biodiversity, expand access to nature, and mitigate and build resilience to climate change. Jointly, we submitted written comment letters and presented oral comments at the June 10th meeting, encouraging a strong conservation standard for the 30x30 framework, or Roadmap to Achieving 30x30 in California’s Coastal Waters.
“If We Save the Sea, We Save the World”: Update on the MPA Petition Evaluation Framework and EAC’s Duxbury Reef Petition
Sir David Attenborough has released a powerful new film, Ocean, in which he states, “if we save the sea, we save the world.” This comes after California’s MPA network was added to the International Union for Conservation of Nature’s Green List, highlighting its importance as a model for science-based marine conservation.
On July 16th & 17th, we participated in the Fish and Game Commission’s Marine Resources Committee in Sacramento, speaking on multiple topics, including the draft framework to evaluate MPA petitions. We also submitted supplemental comments for our Duxbury petition to increase protections at Duxbury Reef, so this unique and incredibly biodiverse habitat can be maintained and enjoyed by visitors for many years to come.
Advocating for Strong Environmental Protections Amidst Growing Threats & You Can Too!
As attacks on landmark environmental laws like the California Environmental Quality Act and the Coastal Act mount, we continue to champion coastal protection, clean water, and public access. Throughout the spring and summer, we’ve worked with partners across the state, taking a leading role in advocating for strong environmental protections for West Marin and statewide, advocating on issues like coastal resources, water pollution, offshore oil drilling, and environmental review. Learn more about the state bills we are tracking, a recap from California Ocean Day, and how you can get involved in legislative advocacy and opposing offshore oil.
Record Number of Gray Whale Deaths in Bay Area Sparks Concern
As of June 13th, nineteen gray whales have washed up dead along Bay Area shores this year, including at West Marin locations such as Point Reyes National Seashore, Bolinas, and Rodeo Beach.
This year’s alarming death toll represents a sharp spike within an already troubling long-term trend. Although researchers have not recorded this level of gray whale mortality in the Bay Area since 2000, elevated losses have been observed range-wide in recent years. From 2018 to 2023, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) declared an Unusual Mortality Event for the species, during which the population declined by an estimated 40%.
Tomales Bay Lease Proposal, Fisheries, and MPA Updates
On March 13th, EAC participated in the Fish and Game Commission’s Marine Resources Committee (MRC) in Sacramento. We spoke on multiple topics, including aquaculture, fisheries, and marine protected areas (MPAs). We raised concerns about San Andreas Shellfish Company’s newly proposed aquaculture lease in Tomales Bay, urged the Commission to continue its harvest moratorium on the severely declining red abalone, and learned more about the MPA petition process, which we will continue tracking closely as we advocate for our Duxbury Reef petition. Thanks to your support, we can continue to advocate for marine coastal issues!
EAC’s Statement in Support of the California Coastal Commission Against Trump Attacks
Governor Gavin Newsom needs to stand up for the California Coastal Act and the Coastal Commission, which were created through voter support in Proposition 20 nearly 50 years ago. The federal officials’ recent threat to withhold disaster funding is a cruel attack on Los Angeles residents who have already lost so much.
Victory for Drakes Estero!
BREAKING! Good news: EAC's petition to turn Drakes Estero into a full marine reserve was approved unanimously at the California Fish and Game Commission meeting in Sacramento on December 11th.
What Does This Mean for Public Access?
The proposed change will not impact public access at all. You will still be able to enjoy the Estero by paddle or foot.
What will Change?
Once the regulation is changed, recreational clamming will no longer be allowed at this location, further protecting the marine biodiversity.
EAC Presents MPA Petitions at the Golden Gate Collaborative & Mapping
On September 26, 2024, EAC was invited to present at the Golden Gate Collaborative meeting, which was held at the San Francisco Zoo. EAC’s Executive Director, Ashley Eagle-Gibbs presented our marine protected area (MPA) petitions. EAC’s Program Director was also in attendance remotely, and she is one of the Golden Gate Collaborative Co-chairs. Other topics of the meeting included 30x30 public comment on the Draft Framework, group, and collaborative updates.
Sara Worden of the California Fish and Wildlife Department (CDFW) also presented the next steps for the petition process, including prioritizing the review of Bin 1 petitions, which includes EAC’s Drakes Estero petition.
Communications Intern Reports from the Sanctuary Advisory Council
EAC Advocates for MPAs and Fisheries Management at the Fish and Game Commission
On July 17th, Ashley Eagle-Gibbs (EAC Executive Director) and Amina Khribeche (EAC Legal & Policy summer intern) participated in the Fish and Game Commission’s Marine Resources Committee meeting in Santa Rosa. The July 17th meeting was focused on Marine Protected Area (MPA) regulation change petitions evaluation process and changes to our existing MPA network for adaptive management.
On July 18th, Amina attended the Committee meeting virtually to speak on fisheries and aquaculture issues including, fishery bycatch evaluation for fisheries management review, and applications for new aquaculture leases.
Victory in Protecting the CA Coastal Act
California’s coast is one of the state’s most valuable and scenic resources. Our state boasts over 420 public beaches and approximately 840 miles of coastline, extending from the border of Mexico up to the state of Oregon. Unlike most states, within the California Constitution, the guarantee to the public right of access to our state’s beaches, ocean, and navigable waterways is enshrined. Each and every person is entitled to the enjoyment of our coastline, its recreational opportunities, its beauty, and the natural resources it has to offer.
Given the pristine and diverse nature of California’s coast, it is of paramount concern that the entire coast be protected and preserved, along with the regulatory mechanisms that protect it, such as the California Coastal Act. Unfortunately, the Act has been under attack recently, where housing is being pitted against our coastal resources. Read about EAC's victory in protecting the Act!
Cleaner California Coast - A Leave No Trace Initiative
Over the past year, we played a pivotal role as the fiscal sponsor for the Cleaner California Coast Initiative, managing efforts across Marin, Sonoma, and Mendocino counties. This initiative aims to preserve California's coastal regions through public education, community engagement, and conservation activities, promoting responsible recreation and reducing pollution. By partnering with the Leave No Trace organization and local, state, and federal working group members, we ensured the use of best practices for environmental stewardship.
Fran Pavley on Coastal Protection: EAC Exclusive
There's a popular belief among some members of the state Legislature that coastal protection policies are preventing developers from building multifamily housing in coastal cities.
But where’s the evidence? When pressed, supporters of bills like AB 2560—a proposal to strip away environmental and public access regulations in exchange for more dense housing in the coastal zone—simply point to the complaints from disgruntled developers.
EAC Team Participates in California Ocean Day
On May 7th, Ashley, Leslie, and Grace went to California's capital to advocate for policies that protect our ocean and coast!
We advocated primarily on phasing out single-use plastic materials, the importance of marine protected areas, making state beaches equitable and accessible for all, engaging tribes and communities in offshore wind, and against AB 2560 a bill that attacks the Coastal Act. We were joined by CALPIRG students who led the plastics advocacy, pushing for a plastic bag ban.
Adaptive Management for Local MPA Petitions- Update
We prepared and submitted two petitions to the California Fish and Game Commission (Commission) on November 30th to request changes in Marine Protected Area (MPA) regulations at two highly vulnerable locations in Marin County: Drakes Estero and Duxbury Reef. We also supplemented our comments on February 1st with additional community support and information. This follows the decadal management review and the need to adaptively manage our MPAs.
Adaptive Management for Local MPA Petitions
Following up on our involvement in the first decadal management review for California’s network of 124 marine protected areas (MPAs), we prepared and submitted two petitions in November to the California Fish and Game Commission (Commission) to request changes in MPA regulations at two locations in Marin County: Drakes Estero and Duxbury Reef. Initially, we submitted comments in March of 2023 and subsequent comments, requesting the Commission review changes to the current regulations based on changed circumstances and to ensure MPA resilience and adaptive management. We followed up with formal petitions in November, including submitting extensive agency, partner, and local support, as well as other relevant information.
State Adopts Aquaculture Criteria + New Application Process
The aquaculture public interest criteria (or guidance) were finalized at the August Fish and Game Commission (Commission) meeting. The criteria outline a series of inquiries and clarify the process for prospective aquaculture proposals (including shellfish growing in Tomales Bay and California waters). These unanimously adopted criteria will apply statewide with broad support at the meeting. Alongside the criteria, an enhanced application review process was also adopted.
We have been leading the NGO effort to increase transparency and develop and refine these aquaculture criteria for the last couple of years. Thank you to our partners for their support in getting this across the finish line! The successful adoption of these criteria results from extensive public comments (written and presented), as well as coordination with staff, Commissioners, and NGO partners.
State of Tomales Bay 2023: Conservation Challenges with Climate Changing
The 8th annual State of Tomales Bay conference took place at the end of September at the Inverness Yacht Club. The day was thoughtfully curated and facilitated by the Tomales Bay Foundation Board, bringing together regional partners, including non-profit and business stakeholders, scientific practitioners, local, state and federal land managers, as well as elected leaders who actively collaborated to address the topic of the day: Conservation Challenges with a Changing Climate. Three members of the EAC team, as well as Board members, joined the important event.
The interdisciplinary nature of the conference presentations gave each attendee access to information that educated about the importance of prescribed fires, Tomales Bay aquatic biology, hydrology, birds and butterflies, as well as introduced participants to Marin County’s coordinated response to sea level rise, student research focused on biodiversity, benthic habitat, biological invasions, restoration success stories, and predation on marine mammals.
CA Aquaculture Criteria Nearly Finalized
An important topic at the California Fish and Game Commission's July Marine Resources Committee meeting was Aquaculture Leasing in California (Item 4) and specifically, the development of public interest criteria to help guide the Fish and Game Commission and the Fish and Wildlife Department in their new leasing decisions, so that the Commission can ensure newly sited leases take into account important considerations such as impacts to our sensitive coastal environment, eelgrass habitat, recreation, and navigation. We have been engaged in the development of these criteria for the last couple of years, and we are excited that the criteria are close to being finalized. Draft 3 will be released shortly and reviewed at the August Fish and Game Commission meeting next week.